The "primary position" is a phrase that crops up a lot in British cycling, "taking the primary", "adopting the primary position" &c.
Certainly taking the lane is critical action you need to do on today's roads, but why call it "primary"? That's asserting that its the main place to be, and elsewhere is "secondary".
Cycling in gutter with buses going past and less than 1m of fading red paint doing nothing to keep you alive -yes, that's secondary.
Cycling along with parked cars to your left while you look in every window to see if there's someone there about to open the door -yes, that's secondary.
But is going down the middle of a lane full of heavy traffic "primary"? No: it's the bravery position.
Do it and you get hated by everyone who thinks they are being held up. They sound their horns, they punishment pass you, they may even brake check you afterwards. You can pedal hard and get up to speed, to lessen this a bit, but that works if you are fit, aggressive and willing to reach your destination after a workout. And in somewhere hilly -like much of Bristol and some of S Gloucs, it doesn't matter how fit you are, you will still be crawling as far as the impatient wanker in the van behind you is concerned -that the van driving about 2 metres behind you while he swears about arrogant cyclists.
It's the bravery position as you need to willing to mix with the vehicles of death: the HGVs, the buses.
It's the bravery position as if you look at the demographics of British cyclists, its males 20+, with the numbers petering out as they get older and unable to accelerate enough to "claim the road".
It's the bravery position as it completely fails to work once you reach dual carriageways or three lane gyratories. Take a lane in a gyratory or a roundabout with a motorway junction, and taking the lane is only for the very, very brave. There's the cars behind you who don't expect you to be there, the cars turning off the road and wanting to get to motorway speed -you have to sprint to clear their exit path alive. Then there's the cars coming off the motorway, not used to seeing bicycles, and not prepared to wait for any they do actually see. You want to be brave: negotiate the A4174/M32 roundabout.
So let's stop pretending that the centre of the road is the place to be. It's only the place to be because the standard UK alternatives are so fucking awful. And because of that, because its the bravery position, cycling is for the brave only.
Some people are happy with that and claim its the place to be. Well: there's Downhill mountain biking as a sport too -but that doesn't mean that you expect families to go to school with body armour so they can safely negotiate 4 foot drop-offs. If you are happy with the bravery position -go for it. Just as if you are like negotiating extreme DH courses for entertainment -great. If you like that, and your commute includes an extreme DH course, you are a lucky person. But don't go round advocating DH skills so that everyone else can get to work or school uninjured.
Take the bravery position if you want to: but recognise that it will forever be for the bold and the brave only -and stop imagining that it's "the primary position" -the place for a transformation in mass cycling to take place.
I call it the "I pay for these roads too and I'm going to stop you overtaking me where you have no room and will push me into a position that will put me in danger if I don't position" Or the "F You, don't push me, I'm an angry mum and my gigantic mummy bike and by fat arse is still capable of damaging your car" Position.ReplyDelete
It doesn't stop idiots from overtaking even more dangerously and pushing past at times. Sometimes I really wish I could even out the odds and carry a gun in one hand to even out the odds. I really do think I need my own lethal weapon too to hold my position on the road.
They say we hold them up, I say half the time they are in my way! especially in town, they hold me up far more than I hold them up, try telling them that, it's like shouting into the wind.
I would say the bravery position is riding far to right (in the USA), gives me the willies, that's why I stay in the drivers position in my lane, much safer.ReplyDelete
Taking primary is a mechanism to try to deal with shite roads and driving, as you say it's not going to get families cycling, it's certainly not going to promote harmony on the roads if you don't remind drivers that it's a legitimate riding style. Cyclegroups should still be pushing for proper infrastructure and driver education, proper enforcement of the rules and proper punishment for those who break them, but I'm OK with it being a recommended technique in the meantime. IME primary does help, lots of people pass too close as they are ignorant of what safe distance is, some may sit and fume if you block them at a pinch point but very few will punishment pass, you're as much at risk from ignorant careless drivers as the aggressive ones and I reckon there are many more of the former.ReplyDelete